The Good Doctor No More

If you live in Houston, you’ve heard a little bit about the Brown criminal trial.

Many Houstonians know (Dr.) Michael Brown from the many billboards that tote the Brown Hand Center, or the commercials in which Michael Brown promises to treat you like his own children.

Ironically, Dr. Brown doesn’t have custody or visitation with those children any longer. And he’s actually not a doctor, so I’ll stop referring to him as one. And that’s just the beginning of the Brown drama, and another post for another day.

Michael Brown was recently charged and found not guilty for assault—family violence, against his fourth wife. Prior to that violent incident, Brown’s history with hitting his wives, his cocaine problems, and his whacked-out personality were well documented by the Houston Press and other news sources.

It’s clear that Brown’s attorney, Dick DeGuerin, simply relied on victim-blaming to sway the jury. Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to watch much of the trial, but I followed the live-tweeting on twitter under the #browntrial hashtag and many of the articles written by the Houston press, local news media, etc.

DeGuerin brought forth several facts that really had nothing to do with whether or not Brown committed assault against his wife. He brought out that Rachel keyed his Lamborigni with two choice words, Brown and his wife were chasing each other around the house yelling, screaming and terrorizing each other, Rachel Brown was having an affair with retired Houston Astro Jeff Bagwell, Rachel Brown went back and forth on cooperating with the police and the District Attorney’s Office, Rachel Brown signed two affidavits asking the DA not to prosecute the case, Rachel Brown didn’t want Brown convicted and sentenced to jail time, Rachel had no bruises or injuries, Rachel waited until Brown left before calling the police, and called several other people first (her parents and bodyguards).

What’s come out in testimony is that Brown chased Rachel around their home. Multiple nannies, children, and bodyguards were present. Brown threw 2 vases and a humanitarian award at Rachel. A bodyguard intervened, and pulled Brown off of Rachel after he had his hands on her. Brown pulled and twisted Rachel’s arm behind her back. No bruises, marks, or other injuries occurred. Brown repeatedly threatened to shut off utilities and stop supporting Rachel and the children unless she dropped charges.

It’s sad, because so many of my clients go through what Rachel does. This case puts the spotlight on what domestic violence victims in Houston go through from when they dial 911 until the jury in the criminal case comes back with a verdict.

In this case, the jury bought DeGuerin’s victim blaming arguments, and sent a message that domestic violence is not treated seriously if you have enough money to hire Dick DeGuerin.

Victim-blaming is when people blame the victim for something that the offender or perpetrator did. It gives communities and people the opportunity to slack in holding people accountable for their actions. This most often happens in domestic violence and sexual assault cases. People sometimes feel that the victim should have done things differently and if they did, they would not have been assaulted. The fact of the matter is that often times, even if the victim did things differently, they still would have gotten assaulted. The accountability should not rest with the victim, but with the perpetrator. Victim-blaming exists, because myths about sexual assault and domestic violence exist. Without the myths, we wouldn’t blame victims, and without victim-blaming society would hold more perpetrators accountable.

Often times, defense attorneys, juries, judges and even Assistant District Attorneys get caught up in victim-blaming. It’s the reason why Rachel has to testify and Brown didn’t have to. It’s the reason why there was a lot of testimony on all of these collateral issues—issues that have no bearing on whether or not Brown committed assault against Rachel. They are red herrings. DeGuerin is hoping that someone latches on to them—believes them. But they have nothing to do with the fact that Brown assaulted Rachel, and she cooperated with the police. If the Assisant District Attorneys office simply stuck to the fact that nothing Rachel did deserved or warranted being assaulted by Brown, it puts the case in perspective. When you start answering if/when/why she’s having an affair, or why keyed his car, or how many nannies she has, how much spousal support Brown’s paying, then you lose the premise of the case– nothing Rachel did deserved or warranted being assaulted by Brown.

Unfortunately, this sorely sends a message to victims. Even if you call the police, you’re going on trial– not the perpetrator. Even if you cooperate, they may not believe you. All those times he said they won’t believe you, he was right– they won’t. Even if you do all the things that you were supposed to, if your husband, partner, boyfriend, girlfriend, wife has money– he or she will get away with everything, just short of murder.

This entry was posted in crime, domestic violence, duders, houston, legal issues, news. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to The Good Doctor No More

  1. Rachel B says:

    It makes me sick to hear stories where the victim is blamed rather than the perpetrator. There are already too many women who are shamed into silence and victim-blaming is just one more reason why women lose the courage to come forward with their stories, so, thank you for making a statement against victim blaming.

    I am curious about your thoughts on how we (society) can be more proactive so eventually the victim-blaming culture fades and perpetrators receive justice for their crimes.

    • Rachel, Thank you for your comment.
      I think that the question you raise is a good one. And I spent a lot of time today thinking about it.
      the first thing that we have to do is make a commitment personally to not blame victims for the domestic violence or sexual assault. The second thing that we have to do is call others out on it when they do. We have to be prepared to say “nothing you/me/she does means that she deserves to be hit/punched/shoved/etc.”
      I think that these are powerful tools, and it’s difficult. It’s often an uphill battle, and you don’t always win. You won’t convert everyone you talk to into realizing that they are engaging in victim-blaming, but it’s a start.

      • Rachel B says:

        Thank you for your response. I completely agree although I’d like to see this personal commitment become a public crusade along the lines of “It Gets Better”. Sometimes it seems like one voice can get drowned out under all of the negativity and victim-blaming but when everyone stands together to make a public statement there is power through a unified voice.

  2. Open Minded says:

    Rachel

    In case you didn’t know, a medical doctor is someone who receives a degree from a medical school. In DR. Brown’s case, Baylor, because he does not practice medicine any long does not neglect the fact that he is still Doctor. Unfortunately this a problem with society, that no one has any respect for medical doctors, obviously (another topic). I find it very narrow minded of you to allow the media to try this case. You are basing you judgement strictly on what the media has presented, without for one second hearing any of this for yourself. Because had you attended even one day of court you would have realize the media was telling the whole story. That in fact in court the defense was very solid, that Dr. brown was being set up by his ex-wife. It’s very said there are women who will fake being abused for money and material things however it happens. I does hurt those who are in REAL abusive situations.

    Hopefully this will help you keep and more open mind in the future and know the media is only telling half truths.

    • Rachel B says:

      Open Minded,

      Regardless of what supposedly happened in this case it is a fact that cases like this propagate the culture of victim-blaming.

      You’re right I didn’t drive down to Houston and sit in court because I have a job and a life so, like the rest of the world, I have to rely on the media (biased or not) to get my information. I’m aware that media is biased, and every story that is based on the personal opinions and ideals of the person who wrote it. That means you have a choice, whether to agree with a story or to disagree based on personal bias.

      As that’s a personal choice I don’t believe you have the right to tell me that my choice was narrow minded, in fact, your entire comment comes across as narrow minded and is one reason why the victim blaming culture is prevalent.

      Before you make assumptions about other people’s intentions perhaps you should evaluate your own.

  3. Sutpen says:

    Victim blaming is often the case in such matters. The man is the victim and gets blamed for everything.

    • redhotmamm says:

      You’re right. Those poor male “victims” with all they’re getting blamed for. I feel so sorry for them, having to choke their wives, beat their children, threaten to kill their families, burn down their houses. It’s just awful how the system just comes down on them all the time and bends over backwards to protect the women involved. Just yesterday I met with a woman whose ex assaulted her on the street, choked her in front of her children, beat up her 4 year old daughter and took her baby from her and the police didn’t do much to help her at all. But he’s the victim. /sarcasm

  4. Toni Bugg says:

    it is cases such as this that lend more credibility to false allegations and/or accusations. In my opinion Mr. DeGuerin did a great job proving reasonable doubt against the allegations of Rachel Brown.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s